Mayflower Seafood Restaurant, High Point, NC - Reviews, Ratings, Tips and Why You Should Go – Wanderlog (2024)

Date

(336) 672-3474

http://www.mayflowerseafoodws.com/

Review score

4.1

out of 5

Very Good

1737 reviews

Review score

3.5

out of 5

Good

27 reviews

5/5Tina LePage

•

The young man who took my to go order was the kindest young person I've met in a long time. He was efficient in everything he did and so polite. The food was great as always! Ty for hiring such a good person to your team!

4/5Stephanie Gomez

•

We went to pick up around back for our food. It was our first time ordering to go. The front entrance is always so pleasant and clean. I was surprised at how unsanitary the back appeared. There were flies inside and out flying all over the place. The kids working in the back were polite and were working diligently to process all orders. It was pretty busy and they were a bit unorganized.The food is always great. I'd rather not see such a gross amount of flies all over the place. The back area did not, however, have an unpleasant smell and it looked clean inside.

4/5Andrea Pike

•

This was my first time here. Carry out. Food was ready rather quickly. Emanuel behind the counter was super nice and went out of his way to provide excellent service. The food was sufficient and it was seafood but it wasn't anything that was "wow."

5/5Landon

•

Consistently quality seafood, excellent service, spacious dining area. I highly recommend the whole founder, pictured.

1/5Melissa Chatman

•

I would give zero stars if I could........ This place has gone down hill! It is sad to see how some people treat customers. We ordered 4 plates and it totaled $83, this is not about the outrageous prices it is about the sorry excuse for a owner. The lady who ran my card for the order ran it for over $833, what the heck. Mistakes happen but how you handle things is what I have an issue with. The lady runs and gets a guy to help fix the problem of them taking 833 dollars from my account. Now this guy says his name is Lo and he is the owner. If that is true you would have got the transaction reversed and gave us a discount or the order free due to them taking all that money. This guy who claims to be the owner calls the card company to get walked through how to return my money which can take time for the $833 to be back in my account and then he says so how are you going to pay? Um I just tried to and now you expect us to pay full price now with what is cold food. Wow and he expected me to be ok with running my card again after they put my account to 0/negative. So I asked him and how am I supposed to pay for the order now after doing what they did to my account. Now I am sitting in the negative with no way to pay besides overdraft my account even further and the ower said let me run your card again. WOW is all I could say, so my husband came in and paid full price for this now cold food. The owner NEVER apologized or offer anything to say they were sorry for the screw up. Now finally home I find cold food and warm coleslaw (also for 4 plates we did not get all 4 coleslaw either). The oysters had no flavor at all, the hush puppies were nothing but grease and the popcorn shrimp were just nasty. I am so shocked in the lack of care for a customer, the lack of professionalism and the lack of quality in the food. The charge has been reversed and may take a couple of days to drop off the account but that was the ONLY thing they did right is refund the money.